I think (but I could be wrong) that this tempest in a teapot about Howard Dean's remark
"You think the Republican National Committee could get this many people of color in a single room?," Dean asked to laughter. "Only if they had the hotel staff in here."
is a fight worth having. I say so for two reasons:
1) republicans look idiotic trying to make Dean out to be a racist. Newsmax:
Republican National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman blasted newly elected DNC chief Howard Dean on Tuesday for telling what he said was a "racist" joke to the Congressional Black Caucus.[...]
The flap over Dean's "hotel staff" remark isn't the first time critics say he has crossed the line on race.
During the primary campaign last year, the former Vermont governor repeatedly told audiences that he wanted to be the candidate of "white folks in the South who drive pick-up trucks with Confederate flag decals."
That would be hilarious if it weren't such an astonishing distortion. Dean's famous remark about the confederate flag, of course, was intended to say that the Democratic party has to do a better job of targeting Southern Whites; he was taking it as common knowledge that people with confederate flag decals vote overwhelming republican.
2) What Dean is saying is essentially correct. The number of black republicans is incredibly small. Bush got 11% of the black vote. Any discussion of the republican party's relationship to African-Americans is bound to remind us of the surprisingly enthusiastic and extensive campaign of African-American voter disenfranchisement in which republicans engaged during the last election.
The correctness of Deans' statement is pointed about by that noted conservative of color, Ramesh Ponnuru, in a statement that's bouncing around the blogosphere:
Give me a break. Dean is saying, hyperbolically, that there aren't many blacks or other nonwhites in the Republican party. He's right. I've been to many, many Republican dinners where most nonwhites present have been serving the food. (Or giving the keynote.) If Republicans are bothered when people make that observation, they should try to make it less true.
The republican party remains the party for racists looking for their attitudes not to be challenged. Just ask some of my family and their friends. Anything that reminds the nation that the republicans are keeping the segregationist spirit alive is fine with me. In fact, I wouldn't mind more of these kinds of statements from national Democrats. Call 'em like you see 'em.
But, as I said, I could be wrong. Tell me if I am.
-- Michael
UPDATE: Jesse's conclusion on this matter is exactly right:
The sole conservative response to race anymore seems to be proclaiming as loudly as they can that they're the only ones who are allowed to bring it up, in the most base manner possible. The mention of race by Democrats is racist, unless Democrats don't mention it, in which case...it's racist. It's an effort to destroy any legimitate outrage at objectionable statements on race, because conservatives have adopted the perverse flip-side of their caricature of liberalism, crying racism at the drop of a hat and claiming "true" racial identity for minority conservatives.
Recent Comments